Dr. Michelle J. McCarthy
- Gender: Female
- Experience: 18 years
- Graduated from: Indiana University School Of Medicine
- Graduation year: 2003
- Sole propriator: No
- NPI: 1235162074
Dr. Michelle J. McCarthy MD
Family Physician
She is located at 1650 West Oak Street Suite 101 in Zionsville, IN 46077. Can help patients with the following: Abdominal Pain, Fever, Hyperlipidemia, Infant Care, Migraine, Pregnancy. Her National Provider Identifier (NPI) number is 1235162074. Appointment can be made via the phone number (317) 733-6300. She is affiliated with 1 practices and 1 hospitals.
Conditions treated
Dr. Michelle Mccarthy, being an family physician, treats the following conditions. Please be advised that this list may not be complete. For the full list of conditions treated, consult directly with Dr. Michelle J. McCarthy.
- Abdominal Pain
- Aging In Place
- Anxiety
- Arthritis
- Asthma
- Autism
- Birth Control Counseling
- Breastfeeding and Lactation
- Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)
- Common Cold
- Diabetes
- Fever
- General Care
- Headache
- Heart Disease
- High Blood Pressure
- Hyperlipidemia
- Hypothyroidism
- Infant Care
- Influenza
- Migraine
- Mold Exposure
- Nausea and Vomiting
- Obesity
- Osteoarthritis (OA)
- Osteoporosis
- Pregnancy
- Prenatal Care
- Prescription Refill
- Thyroid Disease
- Women's Health
Procedures Performed by Dr. Michelle J. McCarthy
ACA Marketplace (Obamacare/HealthCare.gov) plan networks
Insurers selling ACA Marketplace (HealthCare.gov) plans list Dr. Michelle J. McCarthy as in-network for the following 2026 plans.
Health plans
CareSource
Network data as of Sep 15, 2026, as reported by the insurer.
Show all 22 plans from CareSource
| Plan | Plan type | Network tier | New patients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bronze 7500 $25 Generic Drugs | HMO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Bronze 7500 $25 Generic Drugs + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Diabetes Gold 3000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services | HMO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Diabetes Gold 3000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Diabetes Silver 5000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Diabetes Silver 5000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Gold 2000 $15 Generic Drugs | HMO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Gold 2000 $15 Generic Drugs + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| HDHP Preventive Silver 5500 $0 Chronic Care Drugs | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Healthy Heart Gold 3000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services | HMO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Healthy Heart Gold 3000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Healthy Heart Silver 5000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Healthy Heart Silver 5000 $0 Chronic Care Drugs & Services + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| HSA Eligible Bronze 6000 | HMO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Low Premium Bronze 10600 $25 Generic Drugs | HMO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Low Premium Bronze 10600 $25 Generic Drugs + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Low Premium Silver 6200 $3 Generic Drugs | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Low Premium Silver 6200 $3 Generic Drugs + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Platinum Zero $5 Generic Drugs | HMO · Platinum | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Platinum Zero $5 Generic Drugs + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Platinum | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Silver 6000 $20 Generic Drugs | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
| Silver 6000 $20 Generic Drugs + Adult Vision & Fitness | HMO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients |
Cigna Healthcare
Network data as of Sep 15, 2026, as reported by the insurer.
Show all 18 plans from Cigna Healthcare
| Plan | Plan type | Network tier | New patients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Connect Bronze 3800 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Bronze 7900 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Bronze CMS Standard | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Bronze SW 4500 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Bronze SW 7400 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Bronze SW CMS Standard | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Gold 2700 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Gold CMS Standard | EPO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Gold SW 2700 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Gold SW CMS Standard | EPO · Gold | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect myDiabetesCare Bronze | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect myDiabetesCare Bronze SW | EPO · Expanded Bronze | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Silver 3000 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Silver 6300 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Silver CMS Standard | EPO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Silver SW 4400 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Silver SW 6800 Indiv Med Deductible | EPO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
| Connect Silver SW CMS Standard | EPO · Silver | Preferred | Accepting new patients at some locations |
This covers ACA Marketplace plans only, as reported by each insurer. It does not include employer, Medicare Advantage, or state-run exchange plans, and a plan missing from this list does not mean Dr. Michelle J. McCarthy is out of network. Insurer directories can be out of date, so always confirm with the insurer and the office before your visit.
Medicare Enrollment
Dr. Michelle J. McCarthy is enrolled to bill Medicare as a Practitioner - Family Practice .
Bills through: Community Physicians Of Indiana Inc
Based on Medicare's public enrollment records as of Jul 17, 2026. This reflects Medicare fee-for-service enrollment only and says nothing about other insurance, quality, outcomes, or board certification.
Payments received
Drug payment
| Novo Nordisk | $611 |
| AstraZeneca | $465 |
| Lilly | $452 |
Other
| Food and Beverage | $5117 |
Studies
INDIANA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE
Graduated in 2003
Looking for more Family Physicians?
Out of the 29 family physicians in this region, here are 10 randomly selected ones for you to explore.
- Gender: Male
- Address: Suite 100 6866 W Stonegate Dr Zionsville, 46077, IN
- Gender: Male
- Address: Suite 205 6085 Heartland Drive Zionsville, 46077, IN
- Gender: Female
- Address: 7990 East US Highway 36 Avon, 46123, IN
- Gender: Female
- Address: 13590B North Meridian Street Suite 100 Carmel, 46032, IN
- Gender: Male
- Address: 1000 North Lebanon Street Jamestown, 46147, IN
- Gender: Male
- Address: 12174 North Meridian Street Suite 300 Carmel, 46032, IN
- Gender: Female
- Address: Suite 300 99 North First Street Zionsville, 46077, IN
- Gender: Female
- Address: 1555 West Oak Street Zionsville, 46077, IN
- Gender: Male
- Address: Suite 103 1650 West Oak Street Zionsville, 46077, IN
- Gender: Male
- Address: 2401 West University Avenue Muncie, 47303, IN
Questions & Answers
Has Dr. Michelle Mccarthy affiliation with hospitals?
Dr. Michelle Mccarthy is affiliated with WITHAM HEALTH SERVICES.
Does Dr. Michelle Mccarthy have affiliation with practices?
Dr. Michelle Mccarthy is affiliated with Witham Health Services.
Does Dr. Michelle Mccarthy accept patients with Cigna Healthcare?
Yes, Dr. Michelle Mccarthy is listed in-network for Cigna Healthcare through the ACA Marketplace (Obamacare/HealthCare.gov). See the Marketplace plans section for details.
What conditions does Dr. Michelle Mccarthy treat?
Dr. Michelle Mccarthy provides treatment for Abdominal Pain, Fever, Hyperlipidemia, Infant Care, Migraine, Pregnancy. For the full list see this list.
Where can you meet with Dr. Michelle Mccarthy?
Dr. Michelle Mccarthy's office is located at 1650 West Oak Street Suite 101 in Zionsville, IN 46077.